Political Correspondent
Retired Justice Webster Chinamora’s appointment as Zimbabwe Independent Complaints Commission (ZICC) chairperson has raised concerns among analysts, who question his fitness for the role due to his past controversies.
Chinamora resigned as High Court judge in November last year amid allegations of gross misconduct, conflict of interest, and corruption.
The Judicial Service Commission (JSC) had recommended a tribunal, which was aborted after his resignation. His appointment undermines the commission’s integrity, independence, and credibility, experts argue.
Controversy Surrounding Chinamora’s Appointment
- Lack of Transparency: President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s broad powers allow him to appoint the chairperson without consulting the JSC, sparking concerns about potential bias.
- Conflict of Interest: Chinamora’s past actions, including presiding over cases with conflicts of interest, raise doubts about his impartiality.
- Integrity and Credibility: Analysts worry that Chinamora’s compromised reputation will undermine the commission’s effectiveness.
Requirements for ZICC Membership
- Chairperson: A person eligible for appointment as a High Court Judge, appointed by the President.
- Members: Four individuals with at least seven years’ experience in their fields (legal practitioner, medical practitioner, psychologist, and security services expert).
- Appointment Process: President appoints members from a list submitted by the Committee on Standing Rules and Orders of Parliament.
Concerns About Clause 6
- Open to Abuse: Legal analysts argue that the provision allows for potential manipulation.
- Lack of Clarity: Uncertainty surrounds the reasoning behind the different appointment processes for the chairperson and other members.
The appointment of a fit and proper person is crucial to ensure the commission’s independence and credibility. However, Chinamora’s appointment may compromise the commission’s ability to investigate complaints fairly and make decisions based on the law.
Zim GBC News©2024